View single post by Hellcat
 Posted: Sun Oct 23rd, 2011 05:50 am
 PM  Quote  Reply  Full Topic 
Hellcat
Root Beer Lover


Joined: Tue Nov 15th, 2005
Location: USA
Posts: 888
Status: 
Offline
Mana: 

  back to top

Pender, what source are you getting your numbers from? Looking at the Civil War Battles Page their posting numbers out of the offical records.

Seven Days  http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/seven_days_battles_va_25jun62.htm#seve01a1
  • Federal Strength: 105,445
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,734, WIA 8,062, MIA 6,053, Total 15,849
  • Confederate Strength: 80,000 - 90,000
  • Confederate Casualties: KIA 3,286, WIA 15,909, MIA 940, Total 20,135
South Mountain http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/south_mountain_md_14sep62.htm
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 323, WIA 1,419, MIA 85, Total 1,827
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: Unlisted (only casulaties for Rodes Brigade are listed at KIA 61, WIA 157, MIA 204, Total 422)
Note: The page lists that it includes Fox's Gap, Turner's Gap, and Crampton's Gap.

Antietam (Sharpsburg)  http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/maryland_campaign_md_14sep62.htm
  • Federal Strength: 87,164
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 2,629, WIA 11,538, MIA 911, Total 15,203
  • Confederate Strength: 40,000
  • Confederate Casualties: KIA 1,890, WIA 9,770, MIA 2,304, Total 13,964
Note: The page lists this as being for the Maryland Campaign,  it says it includes South Mountain, Fox's Gap, Turner's Gap, Crampton's Gap, and Antietam (Sharpsburg) though it links to the first four.

Fredericksburg  http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/fredericksburg_va_13dec62.htm


  • Federal Strength: 116,683
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,284, WIA 9,600, MIA 1,769, Total 12,653
  • Confederate Strength: 58,500
  • Confederate Casualties: KIA 608, WIA 4,116, MIA 653, Total 5,377

Chancellorsville http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/chancellorsville_va_30apr63.htm
  • Federal Strength: 130,000
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,606, WIA 9,762, MIA 5,919, Total 17,287
  • Confederate Strength: 60,000
  • Confederate Casualties: KIA 1,649, WIA 9,106, MIA 1,708, Total 12,463
Note: the page says this is for April 30th through May 4th and includes Germanna Ford (April 29th), Franklin's Crossing (April 29th - May 2nd), Fitzhugh's Crossing (April 29th - May 2nd), Stoneman's Raid (April 29th - May 11th), Old Wilderness Tavern Chancellorsville (April 30th), Spotsylvania Courthouse (April 30th), Rapidan Station (May 1st), Chancellorsville (May 1st - 6th), Fredericksburg (May 3rd - 4th), Marye's Heights, Salem Church.

Cold Harbor http://www.fortunecity.com/victorian/pottery/1080/cold_harbor_va_1may64.htm
  • Federal Strength: 113,000
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,844, WIA 9,077, MIA 1,816, Total 12,737
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: Unlisted
Note: page includes Gaines's Mills, Salem Church, and Hawe's Shop

Looking at The Library of Congress Civil War Desk Reference the numbers look like:

Seven Days  (the battle has no seperate entry of it's own so there are no listings for strengths or casulaties though Confederate casulties do appear in a chart on page 331)
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: Unlisted
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties:  Page 331 lists the following: KIA 3,478, WIA 16,261, MIA 875, Aggregate Loss 20,614
South Mountain (the battle has no seperate entry of it's own so there are no listings for strengths or casulaties)
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: Unlisted
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: Unlisted
Antietam (Sharpsburg)  (page 266)
  • Federal Strength: 75,000 engaged
  • Federal Casualties:  12,469 (Page 330 lists the following, not including South Mountain or Crampton's Gap: KIA 2,108, WIA 9,549, MIA 753, Aggregate Loss 12,410)
  • Confederate Strength: 35,000 engaged
  • Confederate Casualties: 13,724
  • Page 331 lists the following Confederate Casulatiesfor the entire Maryland Campaign: KIA 1,886, WIA 9,348, MIA 1,367, Aggregate Loss 12,601
Fredericksburg  (the battle has no seperate entry of it's own so there are no listings for strengths or casulaties though Federal casulties do appear in a chart on page 330)


  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties:  Page 330 lists the following: KIA 1,284, WIA 9,600, MIA 1,769, Total 12,653
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: Unlisted

Chancellorsville (page 277)
  • Federal Strength: 133,868 engaged
  • Federal Casualties: 17,287 (Page 330 lists the following: KIA 1,606, WIA 9,762, MIA 5,919, Total 17,287)
  • Confederate Strength: 57,352 engaged
  • Confederate Casualties: 12,764 (Page 331 lists the following: KIA 1,649, WIA 9,106, MIA 1,708, Total 12,463
Cold Harbor (Page 308)
  • Federal Strength: 108,000 engaged
  • Federal Casualties: 13,000 (Page 330 lists the following: KIA 1,844, WIA 9,077, MIA 1,816, Aggregate Loss 12,737)
  • Confederate Strength: 62,000 engaged
  • Confederate Casualties: 2,5000
Then there's William H. Prices Civil War Handbook which gives the numbers as

 

Seven Days 
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties:  KIA 1,582, WIA 7,709, MIA 5,958, Total 15,249
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 17,583
South Mountain (with Turners and Crampton's Gaps)
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 443, WIA 1,806, MIA 76, Total 2325
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 4,343
Antietam (Sharpsburg) 
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties:  KIA 2,010, WIA 9,416, MIA 1,043, Total 12,469
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 25,899
Fredericksburg 


  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties:  KIA 1,180, WIA 9,028, MIA 2,145, Total 12,353
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 4,576

Chancellorsville
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,512, WIA 9,518, MIA 5,000, Total 16,030
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 12,281
Cold Harbor
  • Federal Strength: Unlisted
  • Federal Casualties: KIA 1,905, WIA 10,570, MIA 2456, Total 14,931
  • Confederate Strength: Unlisted
  • Confederate Casualties: 1,700
 

 

 Close Window